Can AI Be Your Therapist?

Two Christian Counselors Answer


Watch Ep 20

Someone brings up AI. Someone else rolls their eyes. Which side of that conversation do you identify with?

In the latest from The Work Within, host John Lin sits down with licensed professional counselors Laura Harrison, LPC-S and Ly Tran, LPC-S—two clinicians who use AI daily—to ask two questions: What new anxieties is an AI world creating? How is AI changing the way people engage with mental health care?

In a survey of about 1,800 U.S. adults, 35% said they use an AI tool for mental health support at least once a week. 28% said they see their therapist less because of it (Ueda et al, 2026). Ly asked his clients and found the same.

AI is here to stay, so how do we engage wisely and responsibly?

In this conversation:

  • Clinical Benefits vs. Limits: Where AI genuinely helps (2 AM panic attacks, session homework) vs. where it can struggle (reading nonverbal body language, catching hard pauses, and holding six weeks of your story in view).

  • What The Fear Is Actually About: Job anxiety, identity, and whether it is even responsible to have kids right now.

  • Relational & Spiritual Discernment: Why wounds formed in human connection require human connection to heal, and why algorithmic averages can never replace the Holy Spirit's prompting.

  • How To Use It Responsibly. Loop in your therapist, ask for summaries, and watch for the 2 a.m. loop.

  • Grounded Hope: How Ecclesiastes ("nothing new under the sun") and C.S. Lewis’s essay “On Living in an Atomic Age” guide us to stay present and do sensible, human things.

Resources mentioned:

  • Ueda, M., Birnbaum, M. L., Liu, Y., Yu, Q., Tian, X., Mirer, A., Ramanathan, S., & Sinyor, M. (2026). Help-seeking in the age of AI: Cross-sectional survey of the use and perceptions of AI-based mental health support among US adults. JMIR Mental Health, 13, e88196. https://doi.org/10.2196/88196

  • C.S. Lewis, “On Living in an Atomic Age,” in Present Concerns

  • Ecclesiastes 1:9

  • John 16:33


Dive Deeper

Check out these articles to explore concepts related to the show.


“What I Tell My Clients about Using AI in Therapy”

Clients keep asking (often in a lowered voice near the end of a session) whether it’s okay that they have been talking to ChatGPT about their lives. Therapist Ly Tran gives a direct answer: AI is a capable teacher but a poor counselor, and the line between the two is easier to cross than most people realize. A look at where these tools genuinely help, where conversations with AI tend to veer of course, and why being agreed with is not the same as being known.




“Living With AI Without Living in Fear”

In this thoughtful piece, therapist Brittany Ertz, LPC, names the fears that AI elicits. This is natural and normal, but left unexamined, the fear can drive us into paralysis, despair, and constant worry. Drawing on C. S. Lewis, the prophet Micah, and a psychological principle called behavioral activation, this timely reflection makes the case for a different posture: get up and keep walking.

“A Companion Guide: Can AI Be Your Therapist?”

More than a third of adults under 50 now use AI for mental health support at least once a week, and the research shows the people leaning on it hardest are the ones in the most distress. Two licensed Christian counselors who use AI every day walk through what it genuinely helps with, where it fails, and four guardrails for using it without giving up what only human care provides. Read the companion guide to Episode 20.


Transcript


Take the Next Step

Ready to get to work? Our team has the training and experience to help you get unstuck, find healing, and walk in greater purpose. The work isn’t easy, but it’s worth it and you don’t have to go it alone. Reach out today to schedule a consultation or appointment.